Creatine, hailed as the ultimate muscle-building supplement, is backed by countless studies. Yet, its true muscle-boosting potential remains a mystery. Can it yield 5% more muscle? 50% more? To unveil its effectiveness, we turn to research, especially two key meta-analyses on creatine's impact on lean and overall muscle gains.
How Creatine Works:
During weightlifting, your muscles rely on an adenosine triphosphate (ATP) fuel source. When this fuel depletes, you can't complete a repetition, and your set concludes. A few minutes of rest allows your aerobic system to use oxygen to replenish ATP, enabling you to perform another set.
Integrating creatine supplementation enhances ATP production, furnishing your muscles with extra fuel. Consequently, you can push out an additional rep or two, sparking more muscle growth.
Additionally, creatine prompts the body to retain more fluid. Initially, this is straightforward as it dissolves in water, with muscle fibers absorbing this solution. This process makes the muscles larger and more robust, enhancing their potential for further growth.
Creatine offers two key benefits:
The ability to perform more repetitions, intensifying muscle stimulation per set.
Muscle fibers enriched with more fluid tend to exhibit accelerated growth.
However, creatine's initial propensity to increase overall water retention and glycogen storage can be perplexing. This can lead to individuals experiencing a notable increase in lean mass, occasionally causing them to overestimate the advantages of creatine.
Not Everyone Responds to Creatine:
Creatine displays fascinating variability in its effects on muscle development among individuals. We can categorize creatine supplementation users into two groups: responders and non-responders.
Responders: For this group, creatine is akin to a magic potion for muscle growth. When they incorporate creatine into their fitness regimen, they experience substantial improvements in muscle mass, strength, and overall performance. Their muscles respond incredibly well to the increased ATP production facilitated by creatine, allowing them to push through more intense workouts and stimulate significant muscle hypertrophy. These individuals often revel in the visible gains they achieve quickly, making creatine a staple in their supplement arsenal.
Non-responders: On the other side, there are individuals who, despite consistent use of creatine, don't witness the same dramatic changes in muscle development. Their muscles may not exhibit the same level of responsiveness to the supplement. Consequently, the gains in muscle mass and strength might be less pronounced. It's important to note that non-responsiveness doesn't equate to inefficacy. Creatine still offers benefits such as improved exercise performance and recovery. Still, the muscle growth effects may not be as prominent as in responders.
The best way to tell if you're responsive to creatine is to take creatine for at least four weeks. Take progress photos, note gym performance and pumps, and compare your results to those without supplementation. Another key indicator is your weight. Try to be as consistent with your diet as possible when taking creatine (assuming you are weight training and eating sufficient protein). Then, after 4 weeks or longer, compare your previous body weight with your current weight. If your weight increased, it's safe to say that creatine works for you!
The Research:
A recent meta-analysis by Burke discovered that creatine could enhance muscle growth by approximately 33%. If you aim to gain ten pounds of muscle over the next 6 months through weightlifting and a well-rounded bulking diet, including creatine, it might boost that figure to thirteen pounds.
However, creatine's effects extend beyond muscle growth. It also increases fluid retention, while bulking contributes to denser bones and thicker tendons. During this process, your body builds new connective tissue, your digestive system accommodates more food, and you gain some fat in a bulking phase. When you've gained thirteen pounds of pure muscle, your overall weight gain might be closer to twenty-five pounds.
This meta-analysis also indicates that the muscle-building advantages of creatine may diminish over time. In the initial months of creatine supplementation, you might experience a 33% boost in muscle gain, followed by a 25% increase within the first year and a subsequent 15% rise over a decade. However, it's important to note that these figures should be taken cautiously, as they are speculative.
Branch and fellow researchers conducted a pivotal meta-analysis that unveiled a remarkable phenomenon: individuals who supplemented with creatine experienced a substantial increase in lean mass and a simultaneous reduction in body fat, with lean mass gains tripling those in the fat loss category. Despite being published 20-ish years ago, the study wielded significant influence, propelling creatine to the elevated status it continues to hold today.
It's important to note that creatine responders will gain weight. That's because creatine draws water to the body, providing the optimal environment for the muscle fibers to fill up with fluid and increase muscle development and performance. Of course, creatine is no magic supplement - you'll still have to train optimally and adhere to a healthy, protein-rich diet to maximize growth potential.
How Do You Determine Your Creatine Dosage?
Individuals weighing under 120 pounds: 3 grams
Those in the weight range of 121-200 pounds: 5 grams
Individuals weighing over 200 pounds: 8 grams
The widely accepted standard dosage recommendation for creatine is 3-5 grams daily. Both doses are typically adequate for all except the largest and most muscular athletes, especially if they already obtain the customary 1-2 grams per day from their regular diet. However, 5 grams is the most extensively studied dosage associated with the benefits sought by most individuals who use creatine. It's also the size of the scoops in most creatine monohydrate products!
Creatine Loading Protocol:
Some individuals undergo a loading protocol, where they bump up their creatine for 5 days, ingesting 4x the recommended dosage, and then back off to the standard dose on day 6. This may help individuals feel the effects of creatine sooner, but it's unnecessary. Creatine responders will feel the supplement's effects within 2-4 weeks without the loading protocol.
The true advantage of incorporating creatine into your routine is its capacity to enhance muscle growth and accelerate muscle-building. On average, it boosts muscle growth by approximately 33%. In practical terms, if you were projected to gain ten pounds of muscle without creatine, its inclusion may increase that figure to around thirteen pounds. However, only some respond to creatine for muscle gain. The best way
Best Type of Creatine:
Creatine monohydrate stands out as the most extensively researched form of creatine. It boasts a strong safety profile and matches the effectiveness of newer creatine variants. Interestingly, in some cases, it outperforms the more advanced types, as seen with creatine ethyl ester, demonstrating inferior results. Notably, the most potent creatine type is the most budget-friendly, so your pockets will be happy, too.
Creatine monohydrate tends to have a grainier texture and often requires constant swirling in your glass to prevent the product from sinking to the bottom. If you're looking for easier dissolvability, try the micronized version, as it provides a finer texture of the same product.
Conclusion:
Creatine is hailed as the ultimate muscle-building supplement - and for good reason. It has been the subject of extensive research, shedding light on its remarkable potential. Through an understanding of its mechanisms, we've uncovered how creatine bolsters ATP production, enabling more reps and greater muscle growth, all while enhancing muscle fiber fluid retention. However, creatine's effects can vary significantly among individuals, with responders experiencing substantial gains in muscle mass, strength, and performance. At the same time, non-responders may see less pronounced results. Research, including key meta-analyses, indicates that creatine can boost muscle growth by approximately 33%, offering a valuable tool for those striving to maximize their muscle-building endeavors. As you consider incorporating creatine into your regimen, remember to reach for creatine monohydrate to unlock your muscle-building potential.
Resources
Safdar A, Yardley NJ, Snow R, Melov S, Tarnopolsky MA. Global and targeted gene expression and protein content in skeletal muscle of young men following short-term creatine monohydrate supplementation. Physiol Genomics. 2008 Jan 17;32(2):219-28. doi: 10.1152/physiolgenomics.00157.2007. Epub 2007 Oct 23. PMID: 17957000
Branch JD. Effect of creatine supplementation on body composition and performance: a meta-analysis. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2003 Jun;13(2):198-226. doi: 10.1123/ijsnem.13.2.198. PMID: 12945830.
Thanks for reading! If you've enjoyed this, you'll love our newsletter!
We send an article weekly with actionable, evidence-based fitness advice to help you with your goals. If you enjoyed this, you’d love our emails. You can learn more and subscribe for free! Click here to subscribe.
If you'd like us to cover a specific topic, please do not hesitate to contact us at support@michaudmethod.com.
We'd love to hear from you!
